At Boyar’s Kitchen Cabinets, we specialize in both cabinet refacing and custom-built new cabinets, all crafted with precision and installed by experienced professionals. Learn more about our detailed cabinet refacing process or explore our custom kitchen cabinets to see how we tailor solutions for San Diego homeowners. Below, we’ll walk you through a detailed comparison so you can determine which option is best for your kitchen renovation.
What Is Cabinet Refacing?
Cabinet refacing is a renovation process that updates the visible surfaces of your existing cabinets while keeping the original cabinet boxes intact. This typically includes replacing cabinet doors and drawer fronts, applying a new veneer to exposed cabinet frames, and upgrading hardware such as hinges, pulls, and knobs.
Refacing is an excellent option when your current cabinet layout functions well and the cabinet boxes are structurally sound. Instead of tearing everything out, refacing gives your kitchen a fresh, modern appearance with far less disruption.
What’s Included in Cabinet Refacing?
- New cabinet doors and drawer fronts
- Veneer or laminate applied to cabinet boxes
- Updated hardware (hinges, handles, knobs)
- Optional upgrades such as soft-close hinges or pull-out organizers
What Are New Custom Cabinets?
New cabinets involve a full cabinet replacement. This means removing your existing cabinets entirely and installing brand-new cabinetry built specifically for your kitchen. At Boyar’s, our custom cabinets are built on site, allowing for precise craftsmanship and a tailored fit.
Choosing new cabinets allows you to change the layout of your kitchen, increase storage capacity, and incorporate custom features that may not be possible with refacing.
New cabinets involve a full cabinet replacement. This means removing your existing cabinets entirely and installing brand-new cabinetry built specifically for your kitchen. At Boyar’s, our custom cabinets are built on site, allowing for precise craftsmanship and a tailored fit.
Choosing new cabinets allows you to change the layout of your kitchen, increase storage capacity, and incorporate custom features that may not be possible with refacing.
What’s Included With New Cabinets?
- Complete removal of old cabinetry
- Custom cabinet design and fabrication
- New cabinet boxes, doors, and drawers
- Custom storage solutions and layout changes
Cost Comparison: Cabinet Refacing vs New Cabinets
One of the biggest factors homeowners consider when comparing cabinet refacing vs new cabinets is cost.
Cost of Cabinet Refacing
Cabinet refacing is generally the more affordable option because it reuses your existing cabinet structure. For many homeowners, refacing can cost 30–50% less than a full cabinet replacement. The final price depends on factors such as:
- Number of cabinets
- Door material and style
- Veneer or finish selection
- Hardware upgrades
For homeowners looking to refresh their kitchen without a major financial investment, refacing delivers exceptional value.
Cost of New Cabinets
New cabinets are a larger investment, but they also offer the greatest level of customization. Costs vary depending on:
- Cabinet size and layout
- Wood species and finishes
- Custom features and storage solutions
- Installation complexity
If your kitchen requires structural changes or your existing cabinets are damaged or outdated beyond repair, new cabinets may be the smarter long-term investment.
Timeline: How Long Does Each Option Take?
Cabinet Refacing Timeline
One of the biggest advantages of cabinet refacing is speed. Most refacing projects can be completed in 3 to 5 days, meaning your kitchen remains functional throughout most of the process. There is minimal demolition, less noise, and far less disruption to your daily routine.
New Cabinet Installation Timeline
Installing new cabinets takes longer due to demolition, construction, and installation. A full kitchen cabinet replacement typically takes several weeks, especially if layout changes or additional renovations are involved. While the results can be transformative, homeowners should be prepared for more downtime.
Eco-Benefits: A More Sustainable Choice
For environmentally conscious homeowners, cabinet refacing stands out as a greener alternative.
Why Cabinet Refacing Is Eco-Friendly
- Reduces landfill waste by reusing cabinet boxes
- Requires fewer raw materials
- Lower carbon footprint compared to full replacement
Refacing is often considered one of the most sustainable kitchen remodeling options available.
Environmental Impact of New Cabinets
New cabinets require more materials, manufacturing, and transportation. However, choosing high-quality, locally built custom cabinets can still be a responsible option, especially when designed for longevity and efficiency.
Style & Design Options
Style Options With Cabinet Refacing
Many homeowners are surprised by how versatile cabinet refacing can be. You can choose from:
- Modern, shaker, or traditional door styles
- Wood, laminate, or thermofoil finishes
- Wide range of colors and textures
Refacing allows you to achieve a completely new look while keeping your existing layout.
Style Options With New Cabinets
New cabinets offer unlimited design freedom. This option is ideal if you want to:
- Change your kitchen layout
- Add an island or pantry
- Customize cabinet sizes and storage
For homeowners who want a fully personalized kitchen design, new cabinets provide unmatched flexibility.
Durability & Longevity
Lifespan of Refaced Cabinets
When done professionally, refaced cabinets can last 15–20 years or more. The durability depends largely on the quality of materials and installation.
Lifespan of New Cabinets
Custom-built new cabinets are designed for long-term use and can last 30 years or more, especially when made with solid wood and expert craftsmanship.
Which Option Is Right for Your Kitchen?
Cabinet refacing may be right for you if:
- Your cabinet boxes are in good condition
- You like your current kitchen layout
- You want a faster, more affordable upgrade
- Sustainability is important to you
New cabinets may be the better choice if:
- Your cabinets are damaged or poorly designed
- You want to change the kitchen layout
- You need additional storage or functionality
- You’re planning a full kitchen remodel
Cabinet Refacing and New Cabinets in San Diego
For homeowners considering kitchen cabinet replacement in San Diego, local expertise matters. San Diego homes range from coastal condos to large family residences, each with unique design needs. At Boyar’s Kitchen Cabinets, we understand local architecture, climate considerations, and homeowner preferences.
Our team helps you weigh the pros and cons of cabinet refacing vs new cabinets based on your specific kitchen, budget, and long-term goals.
Why Choose Boyar’s Kitchen Cabinets?
With decades of experience serving San Diego homeowners, Boyar’s Kitchen Cabinets is known for quality craftsmanship, honest guidance, and beautiful results. Whether you choose cabinet refacing or new custom cabinets built on site, our team is committed to delivering a kitchen you’ll love for years to come.
